How to Get Guests to Come Back to Your Events

The direct answer: Guests come back when your event feels like a world they can return to, not a one-time transaction. That means designing the whole experience in 360 degrees, from the first email to the scent in the room, and making every touchpoint unmistakably yours.

This piece comes from Kelsey's conversation with Rachel Gillman Rischall and Jeana Anderson Cohen on The Connection Code, "From Gathering to Belonging." Watch on YouTube or listen on Apple Podcasts.

The best part of my job right now

At Eventually, we get pinged every time someone sells a ticket. It's my favorite part of the day. A Ghosts of Greenpoint walking tour went live one morning. A founders celebration in Florida. Truffle hunts. Pottery. Mahjong.

Watching all of that go by, you start to notice which hosts sell out every time. It's rarely about price, or even the event itself. It's about whether guests leave feeling like they found something.

On The Connection Code, Jeana asked me what takes someone from "I attended this event" to "I found my people." Here's what I've seen.

Make it entirely yours

Emily Nejad runs Bon Vivant Cakes in Chicago, and her classes sell out every season, fast. Whatever she's teaching.

"She's created this environment that is entirely hers. You walk in and there's no mistaking you're at Bon Vivant. When you're as fully committed to it as she is, you can't help but want to come back."

There's a new mahjong studio in Roscoe Village called the Dapper Fox. Kayla, who created it, is a designer, and her idea is simple: she wants people to want to be there. It's not card tables in a random room. It's design. It's experience. (I'm dying to go. If you want to learn mahjong with me, raise your hand.)

Think in 360

I grew up in Las Vegas. My dad sold commercial heating and air conditioning to casinos and convention centers, so I grew up around immersive hospitality without knowing that's what it was called.

"We went to the new Urban Outfitters at Mandalay Bay and he said, 'You guys know this smell is patented?' When people walk into that casino, you want to match that smell, so the minute they show up, it becomes baked into their memory."

That's the lesson. When you think about an event in 360 (the music, the colors, the design, the way you talk about it through every channel), it stops being a thing someone did and becomes a memory they go back to. And if they can access that memory again by booking the next one, why wouldn't they?

Where repeat attendance quietly leaks

Most hosts know this instinctively. The leaks happen in the parts that feel administrative:

  • The email that sounds like nobody. A generic "you're going to this event at this time" notice doesn't build anticipation. It's a receipt.

  • The checkout that sends guests elsewhere. Every handoff to another brand's page dilutes yours.

  • The guest you never met. When one person buys for a group, the other three are invisible to you, so they're harder to win back.

  • No reason to return. The event ends, and there's no next date in front of them.

Turn the in-between moments into part of the experience

Here's how I described the difference on the show:

"I don't want to get a random email being like, you're going to this event at this time. I want it to feel like Emily's saying, 'Your class is coming up. Get excited. Here's the playlist. Here are some recipes. Here are pictures from our last class.' That's the kind of thing that makes people devotees, not just attendees."

A few places to start:

  • The confirmation: Thank them like a host, not a payment processor.

  • The countdown: A playlist, a recipe, a what-to-wear note. Something that makes them look forward to it.

  • The day-of note: Parking, the door code, who will greet them.

  • The follow-up: Photos, a thank-you, and the next date on the calendar.

How Eventually helps

I'm a real joiner. I'm a do-things-and-have-fun kind of person, so I built Eventually to make it easy for hosts to give off the points of connection that I'd respond to.

All of your guest communications in Eventually are customizable, so you can speak in your own voice. Your calendar and checkout pull in your site's colors and fonts and live on your own Squarespace site, so the brand world never breaks. Because Eventually works per ticket, every guest in a group can get their own ticket and answer your questions, which means you actually know who came. And a branded calendar on your site keeps the next event one click away.

What to do right now

If you host recurring classes or workshops: Write a pre-event email you'd be excited to receive. Add one sensory detail: the playlist, the menu, a photo from last time.

If your space is the product: Pick one signature element (a scent, a song, a greeting) and use it every single time.

If you mostly host one-off events: End every event by pointing to the next one. A date on the calendar beats "stay tuned."

If groups make up your audience: Make sure each guest gets their own ticket and their own welcome. The friend who got dragged along is your next regular.

The bottom line

Nobody returns to a transaction. They return to a feeling, and to a host who clearly cared about every detail, including the ones that happen in their inbox.

The hosts who sell out aren't louder. They're more consistent. Build a world, keep it intact from the first click to the last goodbye, and give people an easy way back in.

Keep reading

Give them a reason to come back

Put your next date on your own site with a calendar that looks like you. Start at eventuallyticketing.com.

WOTW

Websites on Squarespace, calendars on Eventually and stores on Shopify, custom built by your dedicated WOTW team.

https://www.weekofthewebsite.com
Previous
Previous

Group Ticket Orders: How to Collect Information From Every Guest, Not Just the Buyer

Next
Next

Co-host an event on Squarespace without sharing your login